The Descent

Length: 1h 49m
Quality: Very good
Deaths: Some, scary monsters
Age: New (2005)
Type: Supernatural

Pet Sematary [Original]

Length: 1h 43m
Quality: Good
Deaths: Some, mostly animal / semi
Age: Old (1989)
Type: Supernatural, zombie

Pet Sematary

Length: 2h
Quality: Okay
Deaths: A few, mostly animals / mostly semi
Age: New (2019)
Type: Supernatural, zombies

Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark

Length: 1h 47 m
Quality: Bad
Deaths: Multiple, creative
Age: New (2019)
Type: Supernatural, urban legends

Ready Or Not

Length: 1h 34m
Quality: Fine
Deaths: Many, gory but campy
Age: New (2019)
Type: People versus people, dark comedy

The Prodigy

Length: 1 hr 31min
Quality: Fine
Deaths: Some fair, some good injuries
Age: New (2019)
Type: People versus people (child-specific)

The Strangers

Length: 1h 31m
Quality: Excellent
Deaths: Several, gruesome
Age: New (2008)
Type: People versus people

Lights Out

Length: 1hr 21min
Quality: Fine, but pleasantly startling
Deaths: Some, kinda gross
Age: New (2016)
Type: Supernatural

The Heathers

Length: 1 hr 43 min
Quality: Great
Deaths: Many, not gruesome
Age: Old (1988)
Type: People vs. People

The Babadook

Length: 1 hr
Quality: Jake: Good Ashley: Fine
Deaths: None!
Age: New (2014)
Type: Supernatural
Recommended By: Megan Smith