The Autopsy of Jane Doe

Length: 1h 39min
Quality: Very Good
Deaths: Few, somewhat gruesome
Age: New (2016)
Type: Supernatural

Would You Rather

Length: 1h 33min
Quality: Bad
Deaths: Gruesome, many
Age: New (2013)
Type: People vs. people, cruel game

The Fourth Kind

Length: 1h 38min
Quality: Very bad
Deaths: Essentially none
Age: New (2009)
Type: Supernatural, historical

MIDSOMMAR

Length: 2h 18min
Quality: Very good
Deaths: Gruesome, some (creative)
Age: New (2019)
Type: People vs. people, cult

Dead & Buried

Length: 1hr 34min
Quality: Very Good
Deaths: Gruesome, many
Age: Old (1981)
Type: People versus people, zombies

In the Tall Grass

Length: 1hr 30min
Quality: Fine
Deaths: Many although not particularly gruesome
Age: New (2019)
Type: People vs. people, slightly supernatural

IT Chapter Two

Length: 2hr 50min
Quality: Very good
Deaths: Gruesome, other funny business
Age: New (2019)
Type: Supernatural, clowns, urban legend, 80s

IT

Length: 2hr 26min
Quality: Very good
Deaths: Gruesome, other funny business
Age: New (2017)
Type: Supernatural, clowns, urban legend, 80s

1922

Length: 1hr 41min
Quality: Very good
Deaths: Gruesome, yet few
Age: New (2017)
Type: People versus people, historical

The Ritual

Length: 1hr 34min
Quality: Good
Deaths: Gruesome, several
Age: New (2017)
Type: Supernatural, woods